A Director’s Hidden Gains Still Belong to the Company – Stevens v Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd

The Supreme Court has ruled that a director’s hidden gains are treated as the company’s money from the moment they arrive, and that anyone who knowingly helps squander them can be made to pay 

In a ruling that matters to anyone who sits on the board of a private company, it held that a director’s secret profits are treated as belonging to the company the moment he receives them, and that anyone who dishonestly helps him dissipate them can be made to repay the full amount. 

A Hidden Buyer

In 2004, Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd, known as HPII, owned a portfolio of London hotels, including the Kensington Palace, Kensington Park and Lancaster Gate hotels. Andrew Ruhan was one of its directors, and his companies owned a third of it. The other owners, Morgan Stanley and Thistle Hotels, wanted to cash out and authorised him to accept bids above £125m. 

In March 2005, a Madeiran company called Cambulo agreed to buy the three hotels for £125m. It appeared to be owned by Anthony Stevens. In fact Mr Stevens was a front for Mr Ruhan, and the fact that a director was buying from his own company was hidden from HPII’s other directors and shareholders. 

The price was a fair market price, and HPII never claimed it was underpaid. It was also found that HPII would not have sold the hotels for more, and would not have developed them itself.

Profits of more than £100m

Cambulo then sold the hotels on. The Lancaster Gate hotel went in 2006 for £67.5m, making about £7.76m profit. The two Kensington hotels were sold in March 2008 for £320m, and Mr Ruhan’s interests received a dividend of about £95.2m. In total he made about £103.76m, of which he paid Mr Stevens £1.5m for his services. 

Within days, Mr Ruhan used the £95.2m to pay down loans on speculative development projects in Qatar. The projects failed and the money is gone. HPII went into liquidation in April 2008. Its liquidators later uncovered the scheme and sued in 2018. Mr Ruhan was ordered to account for the profits, but nothing has been recovered from him.

The key point: secret profits are the company’s money

The most important part of the ruling is the way the law treats a director’s secret profits. Directors owe their company a duty of loyalty. When a director makes a profit out of his position without the company’s informed consent, the law treats him as holding that profit on trust for the company from the moment it reaches him. In everyday terms, it is the company’s money, even if the company does not know it exists and could never have made the profit itself. 

That meant the £95.2m was HPII’s property when Mr Ruhan received it. Spending it was a fresh breach of his duty, separate from the original secret dealing. Lord Briggs, giving the leading judgment, said it was “contrary to any ordinary notion of justice, equity or common sense” to claim that losing £95m of the company’s money cost the company nothing. He compared it to someone taking your car and arguing you lost nothing because they once gave it to you.

Why the helper cannot walk away

The law has long said that someone who dishonestly helps a director break his duties is jointly responsible with him for any loss that results. But a helper cannot normally be made to hand over profits that only the director made. 

Mr Stevens used that second rule. He argued that the claim against him was really a claim for Mr Ruhan’s profits dressed up as a claim for loss, and that, looking at the whole scheme, HPII had lost nothing. The Court of Appeal had agreed. 

The Supreme Court did not. It held that the spending of the money was a separate wrong, and the question was what would have happened if Mr Ruhan had not spent it: HPII would still own £95m. The court also said it made no sense to let Mr Stevens rely on his involvement in the earlier breach as a defence to the later one. Nor could he offset the “gain” HPII was treated as receiving against the loss, because that would defeat the whole purpose of treating the profits as the company’s and would let a dishonest helper escape “scot-free”. 

By a majority of four to one, the court restored the original order that Mr Stevens must compensate HPII, roughly £95m for the 2008 dividend. Lord Burrows dissented. He saw one dishonest scheme that caused no overall loss and feared the result made Mr Stevens liable for Mr Ruhan’s profits by the back door. 

What this means for you

If you are a director, any gain that comes from your position, such as a commission, a side deal or an opportunity you learn about through the company, may be treated as the company’s unless the company has given informed consent. The safest course is to disclose it fully and get proper approval before you take anything. 

If you advise or assist a director, whether as a nominee, accountant, adviser or friend, be aware that knowingly helping a director spend or hide the company’s money can make you personally liable for the full loss, not just any fee you earned. Dishonesty is the key: the court found Mr Stevens had knowingly helped from start to finish. 

If you are a shareholder or creditor of a company that has been defrauded, the ruling offers another route to recovery. Where the director has nothing left, as Mr Ruhan has not, a claim against those who helped him may be the only realistic way to get money back. 

This is a Supreme Court decision, so it binds the lower courts. Mr Stevens’ separate liability to hand over his own £1.5m was not in dispute.